What if there is more to experience than there is to explain?
Some of the most meaningful moments in our lives arrive before we have language for them. Music brings us to tears we did not know were waiting. The natural world interrupts our preoccupation with ourselves. In the presence of another person, we feel a depth of connection that seems to exceed the words exchanged.
We may call these moments spiritual, sacred, profound, or simply human. The language differs. What matters is that something reaches us, and for a moment, our familiar way of understanding life feels too small to contain it.
Our instinct may be to explain the experience immediately. To categorise it, determine its cause, and decide whether it belongs within what we already believe. Explanation can be valuable. But when explanation becomes a condition for letting an experience matter, we risk closing ourselves off before we have had the chance to encounter it fully.
Spiritual openness begins, perhaps, with a different possibility: we can remain thoughtful about what an experience means while allowing ourselves to be touched by it.
Openness is not the same as certainty
For the purposes of this reflection, I understand spiritual openness as a willingness to encounter questions of meaning, connection, sacredness, and what may extend beyond our usual sense of self, without requiring immediate certainty about their ultimate nature.
For some people, this openness is expressed through religious faith. For others, it emerges through meditation, creativity, the natural world, or the quiet recognition that life carries significance beyond what can be measured. Some people feel no affinity with spiritual language at all, yet know the experience of wonder intimately.
These differences deserve respect. We do not need a shared explanation to recognise that an experience can be deeply meaningful to someone else.
Remaining open does not require us to accept every spiritual claim. There is a difference between acknowledging that we do not know everything and assuming that anything we cannot explain must be supernatural. We can resist both premature dismissal and premature certainty.
A spiritual experience can be meaningful without becoming evidence for a particular account of reality. We can say, “Something in that moment moved me,” without insisting, “Therefore, I know exactly what it was.”
This is not a lesser form of knowing. It is an honest relationship with the limits of what we know.
Why it can take courage to remain open
There is comfort in a world that behaves as we expect. Familiar explanations help us orient ourselves. They can offer stability when life feels uncertain, and there is nothing inherently wrong with wanting that stability.
The difficulty arises when we begin to confuse the usefulness of our understanding with its completeness.
Something unfamiliar can feel threatening, not because it is necessarily dangerous, but because it asks us to reconsider the boundaries of our own perspective. We may worry about appearing irrational. We may have been taught that spiritual curiosity is naïve, or that questioning an inherited belief is disloyal. Some of us carry experiences in which spiritual language was used to shame, manipulate, or silence us.
For someone with that history, hesitation may be protective rather than evidence of a closed heart. We cannot demand openness without regard for what a person has lived through.
The courage I am speaking about is not the courage to override ourselves. It is the courage to remain curious where curiosity feels possible, and to recognise that we can approach the unfamiliar gradually.
Sometimes, that means allowing a moment of wonder to unfold. Sometimes, it means admitting that a practice or community does not feel safe. Sometimes, it means giving ourselves permission to explore without declaring a new identity or defending a final position.
Different experiences, different doorways
Spiritual openness does not have to begin with an extraordinary event.
It may begin in prayer, when we stop performing certainty and speak honestly about what we fear or long for. It may begin in meditation, when we notice a thought without needing to obey it. It may begin in music, when feeling becomes possible before explanation does.
In nature, the scale of the world can alter our sense of proportion. A vast sky does not solve our difficulties, but it may remind us that the difficulty occupying our attention is not the whole of existence. We can feel small without feeling insignificant.
Psychological research offers one perspective on this experience. In a series of studies, Piff and colleagues linked awe with a smaller sense of self and greater prosocial behaviour, including generosity and helping. These findings suggest that certain experiences of awe can shift attention beyond individual concerns; they do not establish that all spiritual experiences produce these effects. [1]
A broader review by Monroy and Keltner explores possible relationships between awe, social connection, and wellbeing, while describing the evidence as promising and preliminary. It also distinguishes positive awe from threat-based awe, which may have very different effects. Intensity alone is not a reliable indicator of benefit. [2]
For me, these findings invite reflection rather than settle the question of spirituality. Understanding something about the psychology of an experience need not exhaust its personal meaning. Equally, feeling that an experience is sacred does not require us to dismiss psychological explanations.
There can be room for both inquiry and reverence.
Surrender without self-abandonment
At the heart of my reflection is a simple permission:
You do not have to control this moment to belong to it.
We can be so accustomed to managing experience that we forget there are things we can only receive. We cannot command ourselves to be moved by a piece of music. We cannot manufacture the exact moment when trust deepens between two people. We can create conditions for connection, but we cannot control everything that emerges within it.
Surrender, in this sense, is not helplessness. It is a willingness to loosen our demand that a moment unfold according to our instructions.
Yet surrender is a word that deserves care. It can be misused to suggest that we should ignore discomfort, surrender our judgement to a teacher, remain in a harmful relationship, or accept circumstances we have the capacity and responsibility to change.
That is not the surrender I mean.
I mean allowing an experience to unfold without abandoning our ability to choose. We can soften our grip on certainty while retaining our boundaries. We can be receptive and still say no. We can stop a practice, leave a setting, ask questions, or take time to reflect.
The distinction matters: surrendering the demand for total control is not the same as surrendering agency.
Perhaps this is the gentler form of freefall available to us—not falling away from ourselves, but moving beyond the certainty we cling to, with enough grounding to remain connected to who we are.
Discernment belongs within spiritual life
Discernment does not diminish spiritual openness. It helps make openness responsible.
An experience may feel compelling without every interpretation of it being trustworthy. An intuition may deserve attention without becoming an instruction. A teacher may offer insight without being entitled to authority over our choices.
We can take what we feel seriously and still examine it. What else might this experience mean? Does the interpretation fit what I know, or am I overlooking something important? Am I becoming more able to think and choose for myself, or less?
The same inquiry applies to spiritual communities and practices. Is questioning welcomed? Are boundaries respected? Can someone disagree without being shamed? Is seeking professional support treated as responsible care, or as a failure of faith?
These are not cynical questions. They are ways of protecting the conditions in which genuine exploration can occur.
A meaningful spiritual life should not require unquestioning obedience. Feeling deeply connected to something does not remove our responsibility to consider evidence, recognise harm, or remain accountable for our behaviour.
An open heart and a discerning mind need not be rivals.
Making room for pain, not explaining it away
A difficult question sits beneath any discussion of spiritual openness: can our spirituality remain open to what hurts?
It is relatively easy to welcome wonder when life feels beautiful. It can be much harder to remain honest when we are grieving, angry, disappointed, or unable to find meaning in what has happened.
Sometimes, spiritual language becomes a way of moving too quickly past these experiences. “Everything happens for a reason” may offer comfort to one person and feel profoundly dismissive to another. An invitation to “choose love over fear” can become harmful if it implies that fear is a personal failure rather than something that deserves understanding.
The term spiritual bypassing describes the use of spiritual or religious beliefs and practices to avoid engaging with difficult emotional experiences. Research on this concept is still developing and culturally situated, but it names an important distinction: finding meaning in pain is not the same as refusing to feel it. [3]
We do not have to turn suffering into a lesson before we are allowed to acknowledge that it hurts. Nor are we obliged to describe every loss as a gift, or to demonstrate growth to justify what we have endured.
If meaning emerges, it can emerge in its own time. It may be partial. It may change. Some questions may remain unanswered.
Spiritual openness can include the courage to pray without receiving an answer, to feel anger without condemning ourselves, or to admit that a familiar belief no longer offers comfort. It can also include seeking psychological or medical support. Guidance from the US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health specifically cautions against using meditation or mindfulness to replace conventional care or delay seeking help. [4]
The spiritual and the psychological need not compete for our allegiance. Our humanity is not divided so neatly.
The ordinary life that follows the profound moment
A powerful experience can leave us feeling altered. But what happens when the music ends, the meditation finishes, or we return from the mountains to the obligations of an ordinary day?
This is where I find the question of integration especially meaningful.
Integration is the work of bringing an experience into how we actually live. It asks more of us than remembering how extraordinary a moment felt. It asks whether we make different choices, pay closer attention, or become more honest about what matters.
A moment of deep connection may invite us to listen more generously to someone we usually interrupt. A feeling of reverence for the natural world may ask something of the way we inhabit it. An experience of tenderness may reveal the need for an apology, a boundary, or a conversation we have been avoiding.
These changes may be modest. That does not make them unimportant.
I am less interested in whether an experience makes us feel exceptional than in whether it helps us become more available to life. Does it deepen our capacity to remain present with another person’s difficulty? Does it make us more willing to acknowledge our mistakes? Can we carry its meaning without expecting others to adopt our interpretation?
The value of an experience may become clearer in the life that follows it.
Elevated does not mean above anyone else
In my original reflection, I use the phrase “step forth elevated”. It is important to name what I mean by that.
I do not mean becoming spiritually superior, escaping ordinary responsibilities, or moving beyond the vulnerability of being human. Spiritual experience can easily become entangled with the wish to be special. We may begin comparing whose awareness is deeper, whose practice is more advanced, or whose suffering has supposedly been transcended.
That comparison can recreate the very separation an experience of connection seemed to soften.
For me, elevation is not a position above other people. It is a deepening of presence within the humanity we share.
It might mean meeting disagreement with greater curiosity. Recognising that another person’s life contains complexities we cannot see. Loving with greater courage while refusing to confuse love with limitless availability.
It may also mean being more willing to say, “I was wrong,” “I do not know,” or “I need help.” These are not failures of spiritual development. They are expressions of an honest human life.
Fear may still be there. So may uncertainty, grief, and the need to protect ourselves. The invitation is not to eliminate them, but to discover whether wonder and tenderness can exist beside them, giving us more than one way to respond.
Leaving a little space for mystery
We cannot force a profound experience to happen. Trying to manufacture one can turn openness into another demand we place upon ourselves.
What we can do is make a little room.
We might listen to a piece of music without doing anything else. Spend time outdoors without requiring the experience to improve us. Sit quietly, if quiet feels supportive, and notice what is present. Allow a conversation to matter without immediately translating it into advice.
For some people, prayer or meditation will feel natural. For others, a more grounded starting point may be walking, making something with their hands, or being with someone they trust. The point is not to identify the most spiritual activity. It is to notice where genuine contact with life becomes possible.
We can approach these moments with a few gentle questions. What am I noticing before I rush to explain it? What helps me remain open and grounded at the same time? If this experience matters to me, how might I honour it in the way I live?
There is no requirement to feel something extraordinary. No obligation to arrive at a belief. No failure in discovering that today, what we need most is rest, ordinary companionship, or the reassurance of what is familiar.
Perhaps spiritual openness is less about becoming someone different than about allowing ourselves to be reached without relinquishing the care, judgement, and honesty that keep us connected to ourselves.
We can understand what we can, question what needs questioning, and still leave space for life to surprise us.
Not because mystery answers every question.
But because a life can be deeply meaningful without answering every question.
M x
References
1. Piff and colleagues: Awe, the small self, and prosocial behavior
2. Monroy and Keltner: Awe as a Pathway to Mental and Physical Health